The Man Who Laughs

Gary Kevin Ware's "Problem of the Week"

Moderator: garykevinware

The Man Who Laughs

Postby garykevinware » 16 August 2012, 1:07 am

This week's title is inspired by two things. First, one of my favorite films of all-time is The Man Who Laughs (1928) starring Conrad Veidt and Mary Philbin, based on the novel by Victor Hugo. You can watch Part 1 of 11 here, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QsLQcOV2YeU, and by following the links, you could then watch the remaining ten parts. A primary part of the plot is the Comprachicos (child-buyers), who carved the grotesque grin on the face of the title character. Ayn Rand wrote an essay, The Comprachicos, which showed how the modern day Comprachicos, the advocates of progressive education, do the same thing to the consciousness of a developing child, http://www.scribd.com/doc/51894820/Ayn-Rand-The-Comprachicos. The second reason for the titles is that Sam Loyd had a set of problems with that title, although in French, L'homme qui rit, and they were submitted for the Paris Tourney of 1878. "In connection with the Paris Congress held in the summer of 1878, a problem tourney was organized in which Loyd hastened to compete. This was noteworthy, because Loyd entered no other foreign tourney between the publication of Chess Nuts and the Strategie Tourney of 1908, in which he decided to be represented as a tribute to the memory of his old friend Preti. I think he had two reasons for his eagerness to take part in the tournament of 1878. He had many pleasant memories of Paris, and the friends he had made ten years before were still the prime movers in French chess; and more particularly he wanted his revenge on Conrad Bayer. "Of course, I shall try one more shy at Conrad Bayer. I have been unfortunate in my encounters with him, and am anxious to try my luck once more." (Loyd to E.B. Cook, August 12th, 1876). The result was satisfactory, in that he defeated Bayer, but he only won the Third Prize. First Prize went to J. Berger. Second to F. af Geyerstam, and Bayer was Fourth."



Sam Loyd Set: "L'homme qui rit" Third Prize Paris Tourney 1878 #5

"The experimental style of problem solving is the slow but sure method. When pursued systematically, it is the most useful, for the reason that it is the only way to test our own compositions for duals and faults that require weeding out. An analysis of this kind must be exhaustive. It is a sheer waste of time to look only at the plausible lines of attack, for the reason that composers try to build their solution upon the most improbable moves. Take the pieces in rotation. First examine the moves of the King; then the Queen, Rooks, Bishops, Knights and Pawns. By writing them out and marking off such key-moves as you have demonstrated to be impracticable, you will be surprised to find in how short a time you can master the most difficult problems or prove the soundness of one you are testing to enter in a tournament."



Sam Loyd Set: "L'homme qui rit" Third Prize Paris Tourney 1878 #4



Sam Loyd Set: "L'homme qui rit" Third Prize Paris Tourney 1878 #2



Sam Loyd Set: "L'homme qui rit" Third Prize Paris Tourney 1878 #3

14 points for sending me a complete variation to all four problems, at garykevinware@yahoo.com , by next Wednesday.
garykevinware
 
Posts: 608
Joined: 2 February 2008, 3:33 pm

Re: The Man Who Laughs

Postby garykevinware » 18 August 2012, 12:52 pm

Thank to Neville Stern for pointing out that I had left a White Rook out, at g1, on the first problem; I have corrected it. Sorry for the confusion.
garykevinware
 
Posts: 608
Joined: 2 February 2008, 3:33 pm

Re: The Man Who Laughs

Postby garykevinware » 23 August 2012, 1:11 am

Here are the answers to last week's problems:
Loyd #5-
1 Qb4 Bf6 2 Rg7 Bxg7 (2...Rb8 3 Bc8+ Rxc8 4 Rb7 ~ 5 Qb5#) 3 Qb5+ Ka7 4 Bc6 ~ 5 Qb7#
1...Bg3 2 Ra1 Na4 3 Kb3 Bc7 4 Rxa4+ Ba5 5 Rxa5#
1...Bg5 2 Rxg5 Nc4 3 Qxc4+ Kb7 4 Rb5+ Ka6 5 Qa4#
"You would scarcely believe," he wrote to Cook, in the letter previously quoted, "that I had so far neglected chess, that I had forgotten most all of my problems, and had to solve them exactly as if I had never seen them; and the odd thing about it was that I found them infernally difficult, until I learned the peculiarity of my style, which I had never noticed before, and then I was able to knock them over at sight in the most disgusting manner. It put me out of all conceit with myself. I find that I have almost invariably placed the pieces to give a false idea, and when I once got the hang of what this was, the solution came very easy to me. I could always solve a problem in half the time, anyway, if I knew who it was by."
"This and the following problem are the incarnation of a parody on this theory of the "false idea." Instead of having the keys the least likely on the board, they are in both cases the most obvious moves possible, which every solver would try right off. But there are several obvious defenses, of such a conclusive nature, that the solver is readily discouraged. In other words, Loyd has here made a difficulty and a merit out of the sheer unlikelihood of the over-plausible!"
Loyd #4-
1 Qxc7 Kd4 2 Qd7+ Kc5 (2...Kc4 3 Ba5 Kc5 4 Rc2#; 2...Kc3 3 Qd5 Kb4 4 Ba5#; 2...Ke5 3 Kg3 Ke4 4 Re2# ; 2...Ke4 3 Bg5 Ke5 4 Re2#) 3 Qd3 Kb4 4 Be7#
1...Ke6 2 Qc6+ Ke5 (2...Kf5 3 Rf2+ Kg4 4 Qf3#) 3 Ra4 Kf5 4 Qe4#
"Some problems, as we have seen, can be readily solved from the suggestive indications, but this problem would be a most laborious task for anyone to solve except by direct experiment. For despite its being a compound of all the features that are generally tiraded against as objectionable, such as commencing with a capture, moving the key piece out of imminent danger, checking, and the like, it is one of my best problems, and was constructed purposely to illustrate my views on these questions."
Loyd #2-
1 Rf3 Ra3 2 Nb3#
1...b6 2 Nb7#
1...Rxf3 2 Ncd3#
1...Bxf3 2 Nce4#
1...Kxc1 2 Nb3#
1...Ra6 2 Nxa6#
1...Ra4 2 Nxa4#
1...Rg4 2 Nce4#
1...Rg6 2 Ne6#
1...Rg7 2 Nd7#
Loyd #3-
1 Qg5 Nb7 2 Nxa6 Nxa5 3 Nb4#
1...Nf7 2 Ng6 Ke6 3 Nf4#
1...Bg4 2 Qf4 Nc4+ 3 Bxc4#
1...Bf5 2 Qxf5 Nb7 3 Qe4#
"In this problem, the effect of the self-blocks is not seen until after Black's subsequent King move is made. Notwithstanding this, the continuation 1...Nb7 2 Nxa6 can be found without any knowledge of the key, which helps to a speedy recognition of the theme, and consequently to a relatively easy solution."
garykevinware
 
Posts: 608
Joined: 2 February 2008, 3:33 pm


Return to Gary's Gems

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron